THURSDAY, MARCH 24, 2011
1. The U.S. Constitution Protects the Right to Unionize
The U.S. Constitution protects and the U.S. public policy encourages the right of workers to unionize. Despite the corporate media and conservative critics that serve the interest of the wealthy dishonest attempts to demonize organized labor the truth is that the government has the power to regulate and pass laws enforcing labor relations and collective bargaining rights. Moreover, this country embraces those rights as a public policy. If you do not believe me trying doing some homework. Okay, you are too busy to do the homework, then read on because I have done a little of the work you.
It is not my intention to cover the overwhelming statutes, regulations, and court cases that support the proposition that the U.S. Constitution protects workers’ right to collective bargaining and to unionize. No one can handle such a monster size task in a simple blog. I will leave that work to others to perform; however, I will provide you with a brief introduction to the U.S. Constitutional provisions that I believe support those rights. It is my intent to give you enough facts that will help you recognize the lies stated by the corporate media and conservative critics who serve the wealthy in their attempts to bust unions.
Allow me to start-off with an admission that no provision in the U.S. Constitution directly or literally addresses workers’ right to collective bargaining or join unions. However, I hope that we can agree that the U.S. Constitutional does not always literally spell-out every constitutional right we enjoy in this country. People, with at least a fifth grade education, accept the fact that many of our rights have developed over the years by principles of law established by the courts and their interpretation of the U.S. Constitution. Hence, if we can all agree to the obvious that the absence of direct statutory language does not make an established right any less enforceable or meaningful, then we can move on to those provisions of the U.S. Constitution that Congress and the courts have found to support the right to unionize.
Let us start with the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. No intense research or citations to law or court cases are need to make the equally obvious point that the First Amendment protection us from government infringement of our rights to the freedom of speech and assembly. Although the law does not specifically enumerate every type of individual, group, type of speech, or events covered by the law, Congress qand the courts have broadly applied this law; and, once again, it is no less enforceable oqr meaningful. Therefore, if every person has the right to assemble with people of their cqhoosing, then it naturally follows that workers have the right to form unions. What more need I say?
Next, the Interstate Commerce Clause of the Constitution perqmits Congress to pass laws regulating labor–management relations. The Interstate Commerce Clause in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution grants Congress the power to regulate inqqterstate commerce, and the U. S. Supreme Court has interpreted this to mean that the government has the power to regulate labor relations. Relying on this law, Congress in the 1930s passeQd the Wagner Act -or the National Labor Relations Act - as we know it today. In passing the Wagner Act, Congress made it very clear that the public policy of the United States favored workers’ rights to unionize and encouraged collective bargaining. Anyone aware of the current attacks against workers will agree that the intent and the public policy reasons as stated by Congress in the 1930s are equally relevant today as they were then. In 1930s, Congress stated as follows:
“The inequality of bargaining power between employees who do not possess full freedom of association or actual liberty of contract and employers who are organized in the corporate or other forms of ownership associations substantially burdens and affects the flow of commerce, and tends to aggravate recurrent business depressions, by depressing wage rates and the purchasing power of wage earners in industry and preventing the stabilization of competitive wage rates and working conditions within and between industries."
"Experience has proved that protection by law of the right of employees to organize and bargain collectively safeguards commerce from injury, impairment, or interruption, and promotes the flow of commerce by removing certain recognized sources of industrial strife and unrest, by encouraging practices fundamental to the friendly adjustment of industrial dispute arising out of differences as to wages, hours, or other working conditions, and by restoring equality of bargaining power between employers and employees."
. . .
"It is declared to be the policy of the United States to eliminate the cases of certain substantial obstructions to the free flow of commerce and to mitigate and eliminate these obstructions when they have occurred by encouraging the practice and procedure of collective bargaining and by protecting the exercise by workers of full freedom of association, self-organization, and designation of representation of their own choosing, for the purpose of negotiating the terms and conditions of their employment or other mutual aid or protection.“
See, the National Labor Relations Act, Section 1, cited as 29 U.S.C. § 151.
In addition, the U. S. Supreme Court has relied on basic due process of law principles of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments of the U.S. Constitution to resolve labor-management cases. Of course, the Fifth Amendment guarantees us due process of law at the federal level and the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees the same rights at the state and local levels. Federal courts have relied on the these Amendments to uphold laws providing for the establishment of minimum wages, limits on the length of workweeks, requirements to pay overtime, the elimination of discriminatory conduct by employers against workers, and many other rights. For example, Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act prohibits employment discrimination based on race, gender, color, religion, or national origin. Other federal laws prohibit wage discrimination based on gender, age, or disability.
Of course, individual states may pass laws giving workers greater rights than those guaranteed by federal laws, but the Supremacy Clause in Article VII of the U.S. Constitution and the incorporation of the Fourteenth Amendment extends these federal protections to the state and local levels. Therefore, a state can never take away federally established workers’ rights to bargain collectively and to unionize.
As I stated above, this was only a brief look into the U.S. Constitution and its provisions that support workers rights to organize, unionize, and collective bargaining. The rest of the homework is up to you to complete but I hope by now you have enough correct information to reject the misinformation out there that workers have no legal rights to bargain collectively or to unionize.
Posted by Steven Holguin from his own site please check him out
http://holguinpost.blogspot.com/2011/03/us-constitution-protects-right-to.html
Says it all so does the picture to the right
ReplyDeleteWhat am I gonna do if they change the rules
Its amazing the money Corporations put out to keep unions out. If they didnt have so much greed and abuse of power. people would not have to stand up for justice.
ReplyDeleteAdministration was there the other night bringing sweets. Nice gesture. But that is not what they wanted or needed. They needed help. It is amazing that they did that. That gesture as thoughtful as it was, never happened before. I have to be cynical. They will do every thing to sway people away. They call them the weak ones. They may evem offer a promotion or more money. It is short lived though. Just refer to your hand book. The Employer can terminate at any time at will. However the only thing that supersedes that is Collective bargaining. (that is the union). We need job security.
ReplyDeleteUnion dues are tax deductible. I have a friend who works at Kroger they are unionized. She loves it.
ReplyDeleteTest
ReplyDeleteYou people in TN have a huge fight a head of ya. It's worth fighting for. You'll have the support from all your union brothers and sisters from all over the USA
ReplyDeleteYou are not alone. You will not have to put up with management abuse in fear of losing your job. You'll be protected All for one, one for all. United we stand
we are all watching and waiting to see how this turns out. it effects us all one way or another, we all need healthcare for our friends, families, ourselves. Lets all make sure we have the staff to provide the care that the corp and state people won't. none of us would want to be in a situation where there was no staff to provide the help we would need. this is one way of making sure big corp have to answer. you have my support!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteWell a very interesting day today. Adminstration here. (on a sunday) answering call lights helping out in the dining room! Never ever has that happened before, not even during the week, and a weekend. But you have been forewarned. Remember they will now try and be your best friend. Where were they before. We have burned up their hotline, begging for help. all to a deaf ear. They just dont want us to unionize. Why do you suppose that is? Because the Union is for us. Look us Union. to be one, to be united. This isnt about money. They spend a fortune to keep unions out. This is about control. They dont want you to be a voice. But Our residents need our voice. They have been needing it for sooo long. Dont be fooled. Dont let our residents down. because if we do. When this is all over for us. It will go back to the way it was, and has been for too long. NO CARE. so they can make their budgets all at the residents and your expense. Hang tough. God bless
ReplyDeleteJust remember the Union didnt come to us, We went to the union. For our residents. We were so tired of leaving their totally exhausted. Knowing that the care we documented wasnt given. With our hours cut. With us being replaced by new people one by one. Remember?
ReplyDeleteRemember the hand book. Employeed at will. Means you can be fired at any time for any reason or no reason at all. We just seen that happen. We need collective bargaining for job security. The sad part about it, is their firing the wrong people. They are going to guess, because they dont even know. You will soon see more people drop off. That might not even be apart of this. If we were unionized none of this would be going on.
ReplyDeleteOh yes the corp says : We have systems in place. We dont need a third party. Really what do they have? Open door policy. You heard how she rant and cusses you out. I dont think I want to go to the open door policy. Then what do we have the hotline? What a joke. They are best friends. Everyone who went to the hotline, ended up being disciplined some way. Even fired. And did the hotline help anyone. No Corp came down, left, everyone was in trouble and we went right back to the way it was. NO HELP. We dont want donuts. Its too late for that now. We want our voices to be heard. Right. for our residents.
ReplyDeleteThe Corp says. You dont need to spend all your hard money on union dues. What Money? They took everything. and Union dues are tax deductible. I need that representation. Look at the protests on wall street. People are sick and tired of corporated greed.
ReplyDeleteYep and dues are minimal. For someone making about 18 a hour pays about 16 every two weeks. That is worth it to me for job security, no administration abuse and the care our residents deserve.
ReplyDeleteI miss the LPN's that they have replaced with RN's
ReplyDeleteIt will be so nice workin stress free. Keep the fight going. You'll be happy you did
ReplyDeleteIf any of you have doubts as to what are management is about I encouraged all of you to go to the Internett http://m.topix.com/forum/city/stanford-ky/TNAGL918M77B9GVSN Check out our suffering sisters and brothers in KY. This just goes to show you. This company cares NOTHING about you or our residents. It sure is funny how they cant afford anything like decent food for our residents, raises etc. forcing 45 min lunch breaks. But OH LORD they care so much that they are paying all of these big shots putting them up in hotels etc for days mind you, because they are soooo concerned about a Union. My First question is "Where the hell u been, I dont know you, you dont care. oh YEAH WE DONT NEED A THIRD PARTY? Our current third party is the hotline, what a joke. Now they hold their heads down, with sorrow saying "we didnt know." How the heck didnt they know, it aint like we have been silent. Oh but they thought the ass wiping monkeys and retrarted nurses would just roll with the punches. Well WERE ROLLING IN THE DEEP. Go back to where u came from, we do not want your captivated meetings. We know your plans. You see these ass wiping monkeys have brains.
ReplyDeleteMy My potty mouth. I sure wouldn't want you taking care of my mother let alone my dog you sick sick person
ReplyDeleteHey potty mouth. We know you are not someones bit@# you are the bit@#
ReplyDeleteIf the union cant do anything for us, then why does the Corp spend so much money, trying to keep them out?
ReplyDeletecan you believe the one above says we have no life, what does that say about the poster, why are they on this site, get back to your life and mind your own buisness. the only thing you can be is a union buster, or administration, both of which don't have employee or residents best intrest, and the way you talk , my word, you are a nasty kind of person, i sure how you are not one taking care of the residents.
ReplyDeleteAnd so the fight begins. Lol. It sounds like you folks really need a union back there. Things can't get any worse only better. And don't let those union dues scare you. It's all tax deductible. It sounds like your company is running a little scared now. They've all ready started brown nosing to the nurses lol lol. That's good, they know your serious now.
ReplyDeleteDon't worrie if this union makes it threw all you nurses will get what you want. The last thing any corp wants is a strike. Cuz in the end they would have to pay all you nurses back pay and then some. It's a win win for all of ya. Keep up the good work. Your not alone. You have the whole union from coast to coast on your side. One for all. All for one. United we stand
ReplyDeleteWhat's going on back there. We need some news
ReplyDeleteReload ur browser there is alot of post and comments
ReplyDeleteOr hit the left or right arrows
ReplyDelete